Forum 2: Creativity in Design
10 Design Points
1. Fun - I had a tough time deciding on how I wanted to word this one, but I thought I'd just settle on fun. If the game you are playing isn't fun, why bother playing it? You want your users to have an enjoyable experience while playing your game, and people don't go out and buy games that are not enjoyable or give them good reviews. The common argument to this is games like This War of Mine (11 Bit Studios, 2014), which can make the user feel sadness for the characters or their situation in the moment, but after playing it they often recommend it since even though it made them sad, they still enjoyed the experience.
2. Interactivity - I feel as if interactivity is a necessary part that separates a game from other forms of media. To "play" a game in the first place there needs to be some sort of action along with it. You don't have to constantly be interacting with a game for it to be good, but there needs to be some level of it for it to be considered a game in the first place, hence why I place it at #2.
3. Narrative/Story - I think the second most important part of a game is how the story progresses and how it is presented. If a story to a game is too slow or too fast, you can become either extremely bored or lose track of what is happening and miss key parts of the story. The narrative of a game is great for transporting the user in a sense into the game, so they feel like they are a part of the characters and the story. A great example are The Walking Dead games (Telltale Games 2012), which made the player truly feel like their actions have a weight to them. At the same time, there are some games that can get by without a compelling story, by focusing on other key elements.
4. Space - The use of space in games is immensely important as the feeling as you traverse the map can have a big effect on how people enjoy it. If the interesting parts of a game are too spread out, and the player often has a large amount of downtime or boring parts, the game will not be nearly as enjoyable as the interesting parts being close together with small breaks.
5. Controls - The "feel" of a game can be a big factor in the enjoyment of a game. If the controls of a game feel smooth and accurate, you enjoy a game a lot more than if you have to deal with clunky controls that are all over the place for the entirety of it. Making it so the controls are satisfying as well can make the combat/movement of a game feel that much better. It also matters to make the controls work for whatever system you plan on putting it on. Some games feel amazing on controller while awful on keyboard and mouse, and vice versa, so it is important to make sure whatever you plan on making the game for works with its hardware.
6. Creativity - A game that allows its player to input their own touch isn't the end all be all for a game, but it is a nice touch to add. There are some games that don't include any input from the player and that's fine, but games like Minecraft (Mojang 2009) and Terraria (Re-Logic 2011) that allow the player to build practically whatever they want and that allows for people to create some incredible works of art.
7. Art/Graphics - How a game looks is an important factor, but it is not an end all be all for a game. It is important to make a game appealing to look at but it doesn't mean that they need to have super detailed graphics. There are games with pixel graphics that are better than some games with hyper realistic graphics. For example, Undertale (Toby Fox 2015) is considered a much more successful game than something like Fallout 76 (Bethesda 2018), despite it having lower quality graphics. The key part is just making whatever type of graphics and art you use is appealing to look at and works with the theme of the game.
8. Re-playability - I am not a big person on completing a game in its entirety and being able to play the exact same story again no matter how good of a game it was. Certain games that I beat like Far Cry 5 (Ubisoft 2018) and Hollow Knight (Team Cherry 2017) were good games that I personally enjoyed, but I feel like I won't enjoy it as much if I go back and play it again since I already played through the story. Where re-playability is important to me are multiplayer games such as League of Legends (Riot Games 2009) and pretty much any Call of Duty, since the game is split up into different multiplayer matches, where the people you play against change, the way you play can change, and even the map can change (at least for COD). I have been playing League of Legends for a couple years now and other than the new patch every 2 weeks, every single match has played out differently and about 51,875,417,160 different combinations of the champions on your team.
9. End Goal - I don't think that a game needs a certain end goal to be considered a good game because it all comes down to the genre of the game and what the developers are going for. There are plenty of great games on both sides of the spectrum, and to me personally, it doesn't matter if a game has an end goal or is just a open world.
10. Singleplayer/Multiplayer - This is the least important factor in my opinion in the quality of a game. I have enjoyed just as many singleplayer games as I have multiplayer ones, and while sometimes I wish certain games were multiplayer, it doesn't take that much away from the overall quality of it. Singleplayer games can give you more immersion in the game you are playing, while multiplayer ones allow you to enjoy the game with friends and interact with people.
Everyday Activity Game
For my everyday activity I would probably choose driving my car. I drive pretty much every day whether it's going to campus for class or to grab lunch. My game would have the player drive to complete different tasks. These tasks would obviously be a little more interesting than going back and forth to a college campus, and the user would be able to choose what kind of path they want to take with their actions. They can either choose to complete tasks for a good cause/organization or a bad one. They can also come across other players and either help them or try to set them back.
Comments
Post a Comment